AI Writing Guideline
This assignment asks students to experiment with AI as a writing tool, document and analyze at least 10 AI prompts and outputs, and develop at least five personal guidelines for ethical and effective AI use. Students then reflect on their AI choices, evaluate the quality of AI-generated feedback, explain how their experiences shaped their guidelines, and revise their work based on peer and instructor feedback. Afterward, they will write a reflection analyzing their revisions, strategies, and audience awareness. In the First-Year Composition curriculum at Northern Illinois University (NIU), reflection makes up 50% of each major project grade.
AI Writing Guideline Objectives
- Further build strategies for planning and revising writing.
- Analyze the output of generative AI and evaluate the output in relation to writing.
- Create parameters for when and how it’s appropriate to use AI in your writing.
- Reflect critically on AI use
This project is connected to the Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs) through:
Genres & Formats
- Genres process documentation, guidelines/policy writing, and reflective writing.
- Formats AI use table, guidelines document, reflection, and digital portfolio submission.
Rubric
- AI Writing Guideline Rubric
| C | B | A |
|---|---|---|
| You have completed all of the requirements in the C column plus: | You have completed all of the requirements in the C and B columns plus: | |
| ✓ You have provided an AI Use Table that includes at least 10 prompts with inputs and outputs. | ✓ You have tried to use AI for all five areas on the AI Practices document. | ✓ You have varied prompts to try to improve the outputs for each of the five areas. |
| ✓ Your AI outputs have been analyzed for quality. | ✓ You have pointed to specifics in the outputs that you think were either good or bad. | ✓ You have explained how you would integrate the outputs back into the original piece of writing. |
| ✓ You have provided a minimum of 5 guidelines for personal AI use. | ✓ Your guidelines cover at least three different areas of AI use. | ✓ Your guidelines are clearly tied to your specific experiences with the AI Use Table. |
| ✓ Your guidelines include an explanation of what each of the guidelines means in practice. | ✓ Each of your guideline explanations includes an example of when or how AI would be used appropriately. | ✓ Each of your guideline explanations provides a specific, real-world example of appropriate AI use in action. |
| ✓ Your reflection includes what grade you think you have earned for the AI guidelines part of this assignment. | ✓ You have revised your guidelines document after the completion draft based on your peers' and my feedback. | ✓ You have explained what changes you made to your guidelines document based on feedback and why you chose to make those changes in your reflection. |
A copy of the AI Guideline Rubric:File:AIGuidelineRubric.pdf
- Reflection Piece
| C | B | A |
|---|---|---|
| You have completed all of the requirements in the C column plus: | You have completed all of the requirements in the C and B columns plus: | |
| ✓ You have explained what you were trying to accomplish with each AI prompt. | ✓ You have explained how you changed later prompts to get better output. | ✓ You have explained what you learned about prompt inputs that you could use in the future. |
| ✓ You have explained how you judged AI outputs. | ✓ You have explained specifically what caused you to judge the AI output as good or bad, giving specifics. | ✓ You have provided specifics about how you would adapt the AI output to make it more appropriate for your writing. |
| ✓ You have explained how your experiences led you to come up with each of your guidelines. | ✓ You have explained how the guidelines would change your AI use in the future. | ✓ You have provided an example for each expectation of how you would use AI in specific situations. |
| ✓ You have explained how your guidelines might be used by other writers. | ✓ You have provided examples beyond your experience of your guidelines in action. | ✓ You have given suggestions for other writers to use your guidelines appropriately and ethically. |
| ✓ Your reflection includes what grade you think you have earned for the reflection part of this assignment. | ✓ You have revised your reflection after the completion draft based on your peers' and my feedback. | ✓ You have explained what changes you made to your reflection document based on feedback and why you chose to make those changes. |
A copy of the AI Guideline Rubric: File:AIGuidelineReflectionRubric.pdf
Assignment Focus
This section focused on evaluating AI writing practices, reflecting on AI-generated feedback, and establishing guidelines for future AI use.
- AI Experimentation: Students experiment with AI as a writing tool and document at least 10 prompts, outputs, and analyses of the results.
- AI Guidelines: Students develop at least five guidelines for appropriate and ethical AI use in their own writing and explain what each guideline means in practice.
- Critical Reflection: Students reflect on their prompting choices, evaluate the quality and usefulness of AI outputs, and explain how their experiences shaped their guidelines.
- Revision: Students revise their guidelines and reflection based on peer and instructor feedback, explaining the changes they made and how their understanding of AI use developed.
Weekly Schedule
Week 1: Introduction
Overview: Introduction to Wp2; e-portfolio update; AI Experiences; AI Practice Workshop
Week 2: AI and Writing
Overview: AI Outputs, Brainstorming and Outlining, Reading AI Policies, following AI Policies, Drafting their own AI Policies, Modeling their Ai Policies
- Key Source on Use of AI
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Read: Using AI Ethically in Writing Assignments | This is an ethical guide to integrating generative AI into writing assignments, offering strategies for ethical AI use across different stages of the writing process, including brainstorming, research, drafting, feedback, and reflection. |
Week3: Curation and integration
Overview: Putting guidelines into practice, explaining their choices in reflection, peer revision, Revision workshop, feedback
Week 4: Conferences and Revision Submission
Overview: Conferences, Revisions