Comparative Source Analysis: Difference between revisions
| (35 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
This project has students collaboratively create a source-credibility rubric and apply it in an individual comparison to demonstrate how credibility varies across contexts. | This project has students collaboratively create a source-credibility rubric and apply it in an individual comparison to demonstrate how credibility varies across contexts. | ||
'''Comparative Source Analysis''' is a collaborative process where students use prior experience with academic, popular, and digital sources to justify their credibility rubric through source evaluation and information literacy. The project concludes with a reflection on collaboration, rubric design, source selection, and audience awareness, which makes up 50% of the final grade in the [[First-Year Composition]] curriculum at '''Northern Illinois University (NIU)'''. | |||
=== '''Comparative Source Analysis Objectives''' === | === '''Comparative Source Analysis Objectives''' === | ||
* Identify and apply criteria for evaluating source credibility. | * Identify and apply criteria for evaluating source credibility. | ||
| Line 15: | Line 10: | ||
This project is connected to the [[ Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs)]] through: | This project is connected to the [[ Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs)]] through: | ||
*[[ | *[[Comparative Source Analysis - Writing Process Reflection|Writing Process Reflection]] | ||
*[[ | *[[Comparative Source Analysis - Transfer and Contextual Connections|Transfer and Contextual Connections]] | ||
*[[ | *[[Comparative Source Analysis - Genre and Style Awareness|Genre and Style Awareness]] | ||
== Genres & Formats == | == Genres & Formats == | ||
| Line 25: | Line 20: | ||
= '''Rubric''' = | = '''Rubric''' = | ||
*'''Comparative Source Analysis''' | *'''Comparative Source Analysis''' | ||
{| class="wikitable" style="width:100%; text-align:left;" | {| class="wikitable" style="width:100%; text-align:left;" | ||
|+ '''Grading Criteria: CSA''' | |+ '''Grading Criteria: CSA''' | ||
| Line 57: | Line 51: | ||
|} | |} | ||
: A copy of '''CSA Grading rubric''':[[File:CSA Grading Criteria.pdf|thumb]] | : A copy of '''CSA Grading rubric''':[[File:CSA Grading Criteria.pdf|thumb]] | ||
*'''Reflection Piece''' | *'''Reflection Piece''' | ||
{| class="wikitable" style="width:100%; text-align:left;" | {| class="wikitable" style="width:100%; text-align:left;" | ||
|+ '''Grading Criteria: CSA Reflection''' | |+ '''Grading Criteria: CSA Reflection''' | ||
| Line 77: | Line 69: | ||
|} | |} | ||
: A copy of the Comparative Source Analysis Reflection rubric:[[File:CSA Reflection Grading Criteria.pdf|thumb]] | : A copy of the Comparative Source Analysis Reflection rubric:[[File:CSA Reflection Grading Criteria.pdf|thumb]] | ||
='''Assignment Focus'''= | ='''Assignment Focus'''= | ||
This section outlines a range of tasks an instructor may assign to support students’ development of evaluative research practices throughout the Comparative Source Analysis project. | This section outlines a range of tasks an instructor may assign to support students’ development of evaluative research practices throughout the Comparative Source Analysis project. | ||
*'''Rubric Development''' | *'''Rubric Development''': Students work in small groups to create a rubric that defines criteria and metrics for evaluating source credibility and source reliability. | ||
:Students work in small groups to create a rubric that defines criteria and metrics for evaluating source credibility. | *'''Group Participation and Evaluation''': Students contribute to group discussion and document design; participation is assessed through individual group evaluations and peer-assessment. | ||
*'''Source Selection''': Students select multiple sources that represent a range of credibility, such as highly credible, weak, or mixed sources. | |||
*'''Group Participation and Evaluation''' | |||
*'''Comparative Analysis Paper (Individual)''': In the individual paper, the shared rubric is used to compare sources, with emphasis placed on evaluative process and reasoning. | |||
:Students contribute to group discussion and document design; participation is assessed through individual group evaluations. | |||
*'''Reflection Piece''': Students reflect on group collaboration, rubric choices, source selection, strategies for communicating credibility, and research findings to an audience. | |||
*'''Source Selection''' | |||
:Students select multiple sources that represent a range of credibility, such as highly credible, weak, or mixed sources. | |||
*'''Comparative Analysis Paper (Individual)''' | |||
:In the individual paper, the shared rubric is used to compare sources, with emphasis placed on evaluative process and reasoning. | |||
*'''Reflection Piece''' | |||
:Students reflect on group collaboration, rubric choices, source selection, | |||
=='''Weekly Structure'''== | =='''Weekly Structure'''== | ||
| Line 119: | Line 95: | ||
! Name !! Description | ! Name !! Description | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[Media Literacy | | Watch: [[What is Media Literacy]] || This video explains what media literacy is—how to access, analyze, evaluate, and create media messages while recognizing common misconceptions about it. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[Whose knowledge is good knowledge?]]|| In this TEDx talk, Giulia Zampini questions whose knowledge is valued and calls for more inclusive ways of recognizing expertise. | | Watch: [[Whose knowledge is good knowledge?]]|| In this TEDx talk, Giulia Zampini questions whose knowledge is valued and calls for more inclusive ways of recognizing expertise. | ||
| Line 131: | Line 107: | ||
! Name !! Description | ! Name !! Description | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Read: [[The Importance of Media Literacy]] || The article explains that media literacy helps people critically evaluate media, recognize media bias, and make informed decisions. | |||
| Read: [[The Importance of Media Literacy]] || The article explains that media literacy helps people critically evaluate media, recognize bias, and make informed decisions. | |||
|- | |- | ||
| Read: [[What is Media Literacy?]] || The article defines media literacy as the ability to critically understand and evaluate media messages and their influence. | | Read: [[What is Media Literacy?]] || The article defines media literacy as the ability to critically understand and evaluate media messages and their influence. | ||
| Line 141: | Line 113: | ||
| Watch: [[Media Literacy Explained]] || The video is a short, animated explainer about media literacy and why it’s important to think critically about the media we consume. | | Watch: [[Media Literacy Explained]] || The video is a short, animated explainer about media literacy and why it’s important to think critically about the media we consume. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[What Is Media Literacy?]] || The video explains that media literacy is the ability to | | Watch: [[What Is Media Literacy?]] || The video explains that media literacy is the ability to analyze and understand media messages critically. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Read: [[Media Literacy (Explained in 3 Minutes)]] || The video explains that media literacy is the ability to analyze and evaluate media messages and recognize bias critically. | |||
|} | |} | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
| Line 170: | Line 141: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Read: [[What Is Information Literacy and Why Does It Matter?]] || The article defines information literacy as the ability to find, evaluate, and use information effectively. | | Read: [[What Is Information Literacy and Why Does It Matter?]] || The article defines information literacy as the ability to find, evaluate, and use information effectively. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[What is Information Literacy?]] || The video explains that information literacy is the ability to evaluate and use information responsibly. | | Watch: [[What is Information Literacy?]] || The video explains that information literacy is the ability to evaluate and use information responsibly. | ||
| Line 177: | Line 146: | ||
| Watch: [[Information Literacy!!]] || The video explains that information literacy is the ability to judge whether information is credible. | | Watch: [[Information Literacy!!]] || The video explains that information literacy is the ability to judge whether information is credible. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| | | Read: [[For Students: Information Literacy]] || The article defines information literacy as the ability to locate, evaluate, and use information effectively and ethically to solve problems and make informed decisions. This is a good source to help students find sources and evaluate source credibility. | ||
|- | |- | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 196: | Line 164: | ||
! Name !! Description | ! Name !! Description | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Read:[[ Reliable sources]] || | | Read:[[ Reliable sources]] || This Wikipedia page explains reliable sources guideline, stressing that a source must be credible for the specific claim it supports and that reliability depends on context. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Read:[[ Verifiability]] || | | Read:[[ Verifiability]] || This Wikipedia page explains verifiability as the requirement that information be backed by reliable, published sources. | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 208: | Line 174: | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Name !! Description | ! Name !! Description | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[Evaluating Sources for Credibility]] || This video explains how to identify credible sources through expertise, bias, peer review, and timeliness. | | Watch: [[Evaluating Sources for Credibility]] || This video explains how to identify credible sources through expertise, bias, peer review, and timeliness. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[Reliable and Valid Sources]] || | | Watch: [[Reliable and Valid Sources]] || This video explains how to evaluate reliable sources by focusing on context, authority, and a simple checklist for assessing websites. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[ | | Watch: [[How to Validate Knowledge? Verifiability and Confirmability of Knowledge]] || This video explains how verifiability and confirmability are used to assess the reliability of empirical knowledge claims. | ||
|- | |- | ||
| | | Read: [[Writing Resource: Evaluating Sources]] || This text provides guidelines for evaluating sources based on credibility, evidence, and relevance to research goals. | ||
|- | |- | ||
|} | |} | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
| Line 246: | Line 197: | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Name!! Description | ! Name!! Description | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Watch: [[Good Practices for Peer Revision]] || This short video guides students through effective peer revision by emphasizing feedback that focuses on meaning, not mechanics, using clear “what,” “why,” and “how” comments to support deeper revision. | | Watch: [[Good Practices for Peer Revision]] || This short video guides students through effective peer revision by emphasizing feedback that focuses on meaning, not mechanics, using clear “what,” “why,” and “how” comments to support deeper revision. | ||
| Line 259: | Line 208: | ||
! Name !! Description | ! Name !! Description | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Read: [[ | | Read: [[Giving Feedback for Peer Review]] || A concise and comprehensive list of effective peer review strategies for students. | ||
|} | |} | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
=== Week 5: Reflection === | |||
Overview: Student groups meet with the instructor in conference sessions to receive feedback on the first draft of their assignment. | |||
<div style="clear:both;"></div> | <div style="clear:both;"></div> | ||
=='''Students' Project Samples'''== | |||
[[File:CSA_-_1.pdf|thumb]] | |||
[[File:CSA_-_2.pdf|thumb]] | |||
[[File:CSA_-_3.pdf|thumb]] | |||
[[File:CSA_-_4.pdf|thumb]] | |||
[[File:CSA_-_5.pdf|thumb]] | |||
Latest revision as of 21:36, 8 November 2026
This project has students collaboratively create a source-credibility rubric and apply it in an individual comparison to demonstrate how credibility varies across contexts. Comparative Source Analysis is a collaborative process where students use prior experience with academic, popular, and digital sources to justify their credibility rubric through source evaluation and information literacy. The project concludes with a reflection on collaboration, rubric design, source selection, and audience awareness, which makes up 50% of the final grade in the First-Year Composition curriculum at Northern Illinois University (NIU).
Comparative Source Analysis Objectives
- Identify and apply criteria for evaluating source credibility.
- Practice collaborative decision-making in rubric development.
- Analyze credibility as part of the research process.
- Compare how different sources establish trustworthiness.
This project is connected to the Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs) through:
Genres & Formats
- Comparative source analysis with reflection.
- Group rubric, individual comparison paper, and written or multimodal reflection.
Rubric
- Comparative Source Analysis
| Criterion | Exceptional | Met | Not Met |
|---|---|---|---|
| Introduction | Your introduction clearly explains the importance of evaluating source credibility. | Your introduction mentions source credibility. | Your introduction does not mention credibility. |
| Rubric | Your paper clearly discusses each criterion and illustrates with examples. | Your paper mentions different criteria used in source evaluation. | The paper does not include the rubric or does so with no explanation. |
| Sources | Sources clearly demonstrate a range of topics and concerns regarding source credibility. | At least 3 sources are used to illustrate source credibility. | The paper has insufficient or inappropriate sources. |
| Process | Discussion clearly and effectively centers on the process by which a given evaluation was made. | Discussion of sources mentions processes as well as conclusions. | Discussion of sources does not include discussion of evaluative processes. |
| Responding to Feedback | You have revised your CSA substantially and/or thoughtfully based on both your peers’ and your instructor’s feedback. | You have revised your CSA based on both your peers’ and your instructor’s feedback. | No revisions to the CSA have been made or only minor changes have been made that do not adequately respond to feedback. |
- A copy of CSA Grading rubric:File:CSA Grading Criteria.pdf
- Reflection Piece
| Grading Criteria: Reflection | Exceptional | Met | Not Met |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reflecting on Your Group | You have clearly explained what methods your group used to successfully work together and have included things you would do differently next time based on your experience. | You explain what methods your group used to successfully work together. | The methods used to work together are not included or are unclear. |
| Reflecting on Your Rubric Choices | You have clearly identified choices in your reflection that you made in your rubric that explain why you designed your criteria as you did. | You have mentioned rubric choices in your reflection related to design choices. | Rubric choices are not mentioned in the reflection. |
| Reflecting on Appealing to Your Audience | You have identified specific things that you have done in your CSA to help your audience understand the process better. | You have mentioned things that you have done in your CSA to help your audience. | Audience reception not mentioned in the reflection. |
| Reflecting on Your Examples and Arrangement | You clearly explain why you chose the examples you did, and clearly explain the specific order in which you discussed them. | You mention the examples you chose and the way you arranged them. | The arrangement of the examples is not mentioned in the reflection. |
| Meeting Requirements | You have met or exceeded all the requirements for the reflection. | You have met all the requirements for the reflection. | One or more of the requirements for the reflection has not been met. |
- A copy of the Comparative Source Analysis Reflection rubric:File:CSA Reflection Grading Criteria.pdf
Assignment Focus
This section outlines a range of tasks an instructor may assign to support students’ development of evaluative research practices throughout the Comparative Source Analysis project.
- Rubric Development: Students work in small groups to create a rubric that defines criteria and metrics for evaluating source credibility and source reliability.
- Group Participation and Evaluation: Students contribute to group discussion and document design; participation is assessed through individual group evaluations and peer-assessment.
- Source Selection: Students select multiple sources that represent a range of credibility, such as highly credible, weak, or mixed sources.
- Comparative Analysis Paper (Individual): In the individual paper, the shared rubric is used to compare sources, with emphasis placed on evaluative process and reasoning.
- Reflection Piece: Students reflect on group collaboration, rubric choices, source selection, strategies for communicating credibility, and research findings to an audience.
Weekly Structure
Week 1: Knowledge/Literacy
Overview: Focus on media literacy and knowledge, produces and values knowledge, why knowledge matters.
- Key Sources on Knowledge/Literacy
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Watch: What is Media Literacy | This video explains what media literacy is—how to access, analyze, evaluate, and create media messages while recognizing common misconceptions about it. |
| Watch: Whose knowledge is good knowledge? | In this TEDx talk, Giulia Zampini questions whose knowledge is valued and calls for more inclusive ways of recognizing expertise. |
- Alternative Materials on Knowledge/Literacy
Some videos and texts might be useful for your class depending on your needs.
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Read: The Importance of Media Literacy | The article explains that media literacy helps people critically evaluate media, recognize media bias, and make informed decisions. |
| Read: What is Media Literacy? | The article defines media literacy as the ability to critically understand and evaluate media messages and their influence. |
| Watch: Media Literacy Explained | The video is a short, animated explainer about media literacy and why it’s important to think critically about the media we consume. |
| Watch: What Is Media Literacy? | The video explains that media literacy is the ability to analyze and understand media messages critically. |
| Read: Media Literacy (Explained in 3 Minutes) | The video explains that media literacy is the ability to analyze and evaluate media messages and recognize bias critically. |
Week 2: Information Literacy
Overview: Focus on in-class library module, information literacy, research skills and takeaways, revisiting the Research Narrative.
- Key Source on Information Literacy
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Watch: Information literacy | In this TEDx talk, Kevin Arms stresses the importance of information literacy to combat misinformation and evaluate sources critically. |
- Alternative Sources on Information Literacy
Some materials that you can use as an alternative to the main article.
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Read: What Is Information Literacy and Why Does It Matter? | The article defines information literacy as the ability to find, evaluate, and use information effectively. |
| Watch: What is Information Literacy? | The video explains that information literacy is the ability to evaluate and use information responsibly. |
| Watch: Information Literacy!! | The video explains that information literacy is the ability to judge whether information is credible. |
| Read: For Students: Information Literacy | The article defines information literacy as the ability to locate, evaluate, and use information effectively and ethically to solve problems and make informed decisions. This is a good source to help students find sources and evaluate source credibility. |
Week 3: Rubric/Credibility
Overview:Focus on understanding reliable and verifiable sources, evaluating source credibility, drafting and testing a credibility rubric.
- Key Source on Rubric/Credibility
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Read:Reliable sources | This Wikipedia page explains reliable sources guideline, stressing that a source must be credible for the specific claim it supports and that reliability depends on context. |
| Read:Verifiability | This Wikipedia page explains verifiability as the requirement that information be backed by reliable, published sources. |
- Alternative Sources on Rubric/Credibility
Some videos and texts might be useful for your class depending on your needs.
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Watch: Evaluating Sources for Credibility | This video explains how to identify credible sources through expertise, bias, peer review, and timeliness. |
| Watch: Reliable and Valid Sources | This video explains how to evaluate reliable sources by focusing on context, authority, and a simple checklist for assessing websites. |
| Watch: How to Validate Knowledge? Verifiability and Confirmability of Knowledge | This video explains how verifiability and confirmability are used to assess the reliability of empirical knowledge claims. |
| Read: Writing Resource: Evaluating Sources | This text provides guidelines for evaluating sources based on credibility, evidence, and relevance to research goals. |
Week 4: Analysis/Revision
Overview: Focus on refining the source-credibility rubric, analyzing sample CSA papers. developing a CSA outline, peer revision, ePortfolio updates.
- Key Resource on Peer Revision
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Watch: Good Practices for Peer Revision | This short video guides students through effective peer revision by emphasizing feedback that focuses on meaning, not mechanics, using clear “what,” “why,” and “how” comments to support deeper revision. |
- Alternative Material on Peer Revision
Some videos and texts might be useful for your class depending on your needs.
| Name | Description |
|---|---|
| Read: Giving Feedback for Peer Review | A concise and comprehensive list of effective peer review strategies for students. |
Week 5: Reflection
Overview: Student groups meet with the instructor in conference sessions to receive feedback on the first draft of their assignment.